Back to blog

HMRC's Definition of R&D: What It Really Means

R&D tax relief represents one of the UK's most generous innovation incentives. It allows companies to claim money back on eligible R&D spend. However, the definition of R&D isn't intuitive – it's a precise technical framework that often excludes activities some business owners would naturally consider "research and development."

Understanding the Concept of R&D According to HMRC

It’s important to get this right because, in order to make an R&D tax credit claim, you must submit an Additional Information Form to HMRC. You’ll need to explain how your R&D qualifies, by declaring your advance, your uncertainties, your baseline and your R&D work.

It’s crucial you understand the foundation of qualifying R&D to be able to describe it to HMRC.

The Official HMRC Definition

HMRC’s definition contains two critical components that must both be present:

1. The work must seek to achieve an advance in science or technology
2. The activities of the company to achieve the advance must seek to overcome scientific or technological uncertainty

Notice what's absent from this definition: commercial uncertainty, market research, or routine product development don't qualify. Newness to market, a normal R&D indicator for many, is not part of the definition.

The Difference Between Everyday Innovation and HMRC-Defined R&D

Your business might innovate constantly – developing new products, improving processes, or solving customer problems. However, HMRC distinguishes sharply between commercial innovation and qualifying R&D:

Everyday Innovation typically involves:

• Market-driven product development
• Routine problem-solving using standard industry knowledge
• Adapting existing technology to new applications

HMRC-Defined R&D requires:

• Genuine technical challenges that competent professionals cannot readily resolve
• Attempting solutions where the outcome is genuinely uncertain
• Systematic investigation beyond routine problem-solving
• Work that could advance the broader field of knowledge

For example:

A company sees a need for an app that connects organic farmers with farmers’ markets. It develops the app using standard practices, including a map and a messaging function. Though this app is the first to meet this market need, the technology used is standard, therefore it is not qualifying R&D.

However, creating a novel algorithm to solve a specific technical problem that existing solutions cannot address would likely qualify.

HMRC’s Guidelines

The Department for Science, Innovation & Technology provides detailed guidelines that elaborate on HMRC's core definition, previously known as the BEIS Guidelines.

These guidelines offer more specifics on the guidelines and should be consulted by anyone looking to make a claim. The guidelines provide examples for some of the more confusing aspects of qualification and commentary on some of the more common questions.

Scientific or Technological Uncertainty

Breaking Down "Uncertainty"

Scientific or technological uncertainty exists when competent professionals in the field cannot readily determine whether something is scientifically possible or technologically feasible, or how to achieve it in practice.

This uncertainty must be genuine and substantial. Questions like "Will this marketing campaign work?" or "Can we reduce costs?" don't constitute scientific uncertainty.

Competent Professionals

The "competent professional" test provides HMRC's benchmark for evaluating uncertainty. A competent professional is someone with relevant technical knowledge and experience who would be expected to know the current state of science or technology in the specific field.

Importantly, this doesn't mean world-leading experts. HMRC considers competent professionals to be those with appropriate qualifications and practical experience who would typically work on similar technical challenges.

These professionals should be able to define what is and isn’t a genuine uncertainty in their specific field.

Advance in Science or Technology

Breaking Down an "Advance"

An advance in science or technology means extending overall knowledge or capability in the field – not just your company's internal capabilities. The advance doesn't need to be groundbreaking, but it must represent genuine progress beyond what was previously possible or known.

Crucially, unsuccessful projects can still qualify if they were genuinely attempting to achieve an advance. The requirement is to seek an advance, not necessarily to achieve one.

A Compelling Baseline in Science or Technology

To demonstrate an advance, you must establish a clear scientific or technological baseline – the existing state of knowledge or capability before your project began. This is one of the questions that you must answer within the AIF.

Many R&D claims fail because businesses cannot adequately demonstrate this baseline, particularly when their internal teams have strong expertise that makes challenges seem more routine than they actually are.

Why Does This Matter?

First and foremost, you’ll need to describe your qualifying R&D to HMRC in your Additional Information Form. Understanding what qualifies as R&D is the very first step to making a robust R&D tax credit claim and this should be reason enough to get to grips with the basics of qualifying R&D.

Risk of HMRC Enquiries

However, outside of the desire to make a genuine claim, there is also a risk if you submit a claim without proper due diligence. Overcoming compliance checks from HMRC require significant effort, time and resources.

HMRC has significantly increased its scrutiny of R&D claims in recent years. Compliance check rates have risen sharply, particularly for first-time claimants and companies claiming substantial amounts relative to their size.

Common triggers for HMRC enquiries include:

• High R&D claims relative to company turnover
• Significant increases in claimed amounts
• Claims spanning multiple technical areas
• Poor documentation supporting technical uncertainty
• Generic or commercially-focused project descriptions

One of the ways to mitigate this risk is to prepare a robust case for your project being R&D. This reduces your likelihood of being picked up on the basis of the technical content of your claim.

However, there is still a chance you could be investigated over the size of your claim, or even just randomly. Preparing your arguments in advance is the best way to put an end to a compliance check as quickly as possible.

How to Prepare for an HMRC Compliance Check

When HMRC opens an enquiry, they'll typically request detailed documentation proving that your claimed activities meet their R&D definition. Preparation should include:

Technical Documentation:

• Detailed project descriptions
• Evidence of scientific or technological uncertainty
• Documentation of systematic investigation methods
• Records of competent professional input

Project Management Records:

• Clear delineation between R&D and non-R&D activities
• Time tracking systems that isolate qualifying work
• Decision-making records showing technical problem-solving

Financial Documentation:

• Accurate cost allocation to R&D activities
• Separation of qualifying and non-qualifying expenditure
• Supporting records for all claimed costs

The key is demonstrating that your activities genuinely sought to resolve scientific or technological uncertainty through systematic investigation.

Examples of Qualifying Projects

Qualifying R&D projects might involve:

Software Development:

• Creating novel algorithms to solve specific technical problems
• Developing new approaches to data processing or analysis
• Investigating whether theoretical computing concepts can be practically implemented

Manufacturing Innovation:

• Developing new production processes where technical feasibility is uncertain
• Investigating novel materials or techniques with unknown performance characteristics
• Attempting to achieve technical specifications that existing methods cannot meet

Engineering Solutions:

• Designing systems where the interaction of components creates technical uncertainty
• Investigating whether engineering solutions can meet conflicting technical requirements
• Developing approaches to overcome specific physical or technical limitations

Non-Qualifying Activities

However, at Tax Cloud, we often see businesses mistakenly looking to claim activities related to qualifying projects, or even entire projects that are simply not eligible.

These kinds of ineligible projects might include:

Routine Development Work:

• Customising existing software for new applications
• Implementing known technologies in standard ways
• Quality assurance and testing of proven solutions

Commercial or Market-Driven Activities:

• Market research and analysis
• Cost reduction exercises using established methods
• Routine product improvements based on customer feedback

Administrative and Support Functions:

• Project management of R&D projects (unless involving technical problem-solving)
• General business planning and strategy
• Routine maintenance and debugging

The distinction often lies in whether the activity involves resolving genuine technical uncertainty or simply applying existing knowledge.

Conclusion

HMRC's definition of R&D creates a specific technical framework that often differs significantly from business intuition about research and development activities.

The key to successful R&D claims lies in recognising when your innovation work crosses the threshold from routine development into genuine technical investigation. This requires careful documentation of technical challenges, systematic approaches to problem-solving, and clear evidence of uncertainty that competent professionals cannot readily resolve.

If you're unsure whether your innovation activities qualify for R&D relief, or if you need support preparing documentation for an HMRC enquiry, our specialist team can help you navigate these complex requirements and maximise your legitimate claims while avoiding compliance risks.

Ready to evaluate your R&D activities against HMRC's requirements? Get in touch with our R&D specialists for a comprehensive assessment of your potential claim.